Home
/
Investment strategies
/
Risk management
/

Critiquing the value of bitcoin: a flawed argument

Bitcoin's Value Debate | Users Challenge Simplistic Assertions

By

Fatima El-Khateeb

Nov 22, 2025, 12:46 AM

Edited By

Elena Ivanova

Updated

Nov 22, 2025, 09:53 AM

2 minutes to read

A person holding a Bitcoin symbol, looking puzzled while sitting at a desk filled with financial charts and graphs.
popular

A wave of criticism is brewing among crypto enthusiasts as they address the argument that "1 BTC = 1 BTC". Many users consider this assertion overly simplistic, arguing it overlooks the complexities surrounding Bitcoin's role in finance amid ongoing volatility.

Context of the Critique

In user boards, participants are pushing back against the notion that Bitcoin retains a static value. They emphasize its volatility and how it reflects broader market sentiments. According to one commenter, "Price inflation is way up if you’re paying in bitcoin," highlighting that Bitcoin's effectiveness as a hedge against inflation largely depends on it appreciating in value.

Problems with the Argument

Users criticize the simplistic comparisons frequently drawn about Bitcoin's value.

  1. Utility as a Dollar Value: Many assert that Bitcoin lacks tangible utility right now. One participant remarked, "The problem is that: There is no utility for BTC as of present."

  2. Price Fluctuations: The persistent price fluctuations challenge the effectiveness of simplistic statements. A user noted, "1 bitcoin today = 1.4 bitcoins last month," showcasing the rapid price changes that distort evaluations.

  3. Comparison Issues: Comparing Bitcoin to commodities like gold or even potatoes gets mixed reactions. "They call that a discount!'" quipped a comment, illustrating how some views on Bitcoin differ significantly from tangible assets.

"1 BTC = 1 BTC Not for the whales lol. They laugh at what it costs to get 1 BTC these days."

Sentiment and Insights

The conversation reflects a diverse sentiment, with clear divisions on valuation and utility.

  • πŸ”„ The digital currency community remains polarized over defending Bitcoin's static value assertions.

  • πŸ’” Many users express that Bitcoin's practical application as a currency appears bleak.

  • πŸ€” The dismissive phrase "1 BTC = 1 BTC" continues to ignite discussions rife with skepticism and doubt.

What’s Next for Crypto?

As debates deepen, observers predict that volatility will shape Bitcoin's narrative into 2025. Experts estimate a 70% likelihood that more businesses will integrate cryptocurrencies into their frameworks, contrasting quickly with regulatory scrutiny, which may lead to clearer lines between stablecoins and volatile assets.

The public remains skeptical, and understanding Bitcoin's role might require continuous reevaluation. As the dialogue evolves, the underlying complexities of cryptocurrencies will likely dominate discussions, urging a need for clarity in their market positions.